Missouri Lawsuit Filed to Prevent Taxpayer Financing of Professional Sports Teams

Today Bevis Schock and I filed a lawsuit against the State of Missouri, the Missouri Governor and Attorney General regarding Senate Bill 3, which provides that Missouri will provide illegal subsidies to the KC Chiefs and KC Royals. Our Plaintiffs are State Senator Michael Moon, State Representative Bryant Wolfin and citizen activist Ron Calzone of Maries County. Plaintiffs assert that Missouri taxpayers should not be forced to fund professional sports teams. Here is today's press release, which further describes the claims .The Plaintiffs are asking the court to declare SB 3 unconstitutional and to enjoin its enforcement. Bevis and I have been co-counseling on a variety of cases over the past few years. It is an honor to work with him.

"JULY 31, 2025

PRESS RELEASE -- FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

CHALLENGE TO CHIEFS AND ROYALS STADIUM SUBSIDIES

Three Plaintiffs have just filed 25AC-CC05910 - Moon v. State, a lawsuit in Cole County Circuit Court challenging the constitutionality of Senate Bill 3, the Bill passed in the June Extraordinary Session of the General Assembly which gives around $1.2 billion in subsidies for the Chiefs and Royals. See attached proof of filing and copy of the Petition.

The Plaintiffs are State Senator Michael Moon, Senate Dist 29, (Southwest Missouri) (GOP), State Representative Bryant Wolfin, House Dist. 145 (Ste. Genevieve) (GOP), and citizen activist Ron Calzone, Maries County (Central Missouri). The Defendants are the State of Missouri, Governor Michael Kehoe and Attorney General Andrew Bailey. Counsel for the Plaintiffs are W. Bevis Schock and Erich Vieth, both of St. Louis. This suit is supported financially by the Article 3 Institute, a 501(c)(4), a charitable organization.

As Truly Agreed to and Finally Passed the Bill, among other provisions, (1) provides taxpayer subsidies to the owners of sports teams for building and improving stadiums and even privately owned headquarters, (2) allows holders of elective office to use campaign funds to pay attorneys to defend legal challenges brought against them related to the Bill, (which would otherwise be a forbidden use of campaign funds for a personal purpose), and (3) provides property tax relief, via tax credits, to homeowner disaster victims, and (4) allows some but not all counties to vote on the adoption of the tax credits for property tax relief for all homeowners.

The suit asks the court to declare SB 3 unconstitutional and to enjoin its enforcement. The Bill’s quick trip through the legislature was unconstitutional because it violated the Missouri constitution’s rules requiring bills to have a clear title, a single subject, and a single purpose all the way through the legislative process. The Bill is also unconstitutional because it grants taxpayer money to private for-profit entities (Chiefs and Royal). Such grants are not “primarily public.” The Bill also violates the Missouri Constitution in that it is a “special law.”

The stadium subsidies are a bribe paid to sports team owners to meet their extortion demand to stop them from leaving Missouri for Kansas. The way the numbers work, it appears the legislature and the governor are sticking taxpayers with most of the salary of Chiefs Quarterback Patrick Mahomes. See para. 15. (Plaintiffs agree that he is one GREAT football player!).

An entrepreneur in the entertainment industry should pay for his own hall.

The trial court loser will have a direct appeal to the Missouri Supreme Court. "

Continue ReadingMissouri Lawsuit Filed to Prevent Taxpayer Financing of Professional Sports Teams

Sports fans as religious believers

Writing for Psychology Today, Nigel Barber asks whether modern day spectator sports function as religions. The evidence suggests that the answer is yes:

"The similarities between sport fandom and organized religion are striking. Consider the vocabulary associated with both: faith, devotion, worship, ritual, dedication, sacrifice, commitment, spirit, prayer, suffering, festival, and celebration." . . . [S]pectators worship other human beings, their achievements, and the groups to which they belong." And . . . sports stadia and arenas resemble "cathedrals where followers gather to worship their heroes and pray for their successes."

Fans wear the team colors and carry its flags, icons, and mascots. Then there is repetitive chanting of team encouragement, hand-clapping, booing the other team, doing the wave, and so forth. The singing of an anthem at a sporting event likely has similar psychological effects as the singing of a hymn in church. . . . As a group, sports fans are fairly religious, according to research. It is also curious that as religious attendance rates have dropped off in recent decades, interest in sport spectatorship has soared. . .

[F]ans are highly committed to their favored stars and teams in a way that gives focus and meaning to their daily lives. In addition, sports spectatorship is a transformative experience through which fans escape their humdrum lives, just as religious experiences help the faithful to transcend their everyday existence.

The same issue of Psychology Today features the ex-gods and the ex-goddesses of the sports/religions. Their sports careers often end with a thud.

Continue ReadingSports fans as religious believers

The Clueless Competitor – an ethical dilemma

As you may or may not know, I am a documentary filmmaker working mostly within the very inbred and insular world of bodybuilding. From the local level to the pros, I have covered it all. A few weeks ago I was in New York shooting footage for a new documentary…

Continue ReadingThe Clueless Competitor – an ethical dilemma

Can Amateur Athletics Threaten Internet Integrity?

I'm talking about an assault on the internet of Olympic proportions. Literally. The Olympics could possibly bring the internet infrastructure to its knees. Or not. Experts say 60% chance of no-problem, vs. 10% chance of total crisis. According to this discussion, the over 300 channels of live internet feed from…

Continue ReadingCan Amateur Athletics Threaten Internet Integrity?

Super Bull

     It’s not yet football season, but I’m already hearing rumblings, and I’ve seen news bits on the the Rams cheerleaders.  But since, to my mind, all professional sports is of a fabric, some worse than others, I thought I’d post this essay I wrote some time ago, with modifications.
     An acquaintance asked me a while ago if I intended to watch the play-offs and I responded–automatically and immediately–with “what play-offs?”
     Such honesty can get you seriously dissed in this country.  But, yes, Virginia, there are people in the United States who know virtually nothing about pro sports.  Or semi-pro.  Or amateur.  Nothing about sports.
     When the Cardinals (my home team) are in the play-offs or whatever, heading for a pennant–which they do more regularly than I care to recall–I suffer at work, because suddenly none of the radios are playing music, but carrying the do-or-die commentary on the day’s Game.  People move about rivetted.  They have a glazed look in their eyes.  I’ve seen that look in others–religious fanatics in the grip of glossolalia.
     I don’t get it.
     No, wait.  Let me be clearer.  I don’t GET IT!
     Is it possible to grow up in this culture and not have an appreciation for athletics?  Sure, but that’s not what I don’t get. And for the most part, I’m not sure most sports fans have such an appreciation themselves.  I mean, I don’t think all those people who tuned in to watch the Team of the Month take another Super Bowl …

Share

Continue ReadingSuper Bull