Science and Religion: Differences?

We have all been through one cycle after another of debate with someone who insists that science is a religion. This is a tiresome argument on one level because it is one with all sorts of things that fall under the category of "I know it when I see it." …

Continue ReadingScience and Religion: Differences?

Belief based on evidence vs. authority, and the appropriateness of extrapolation

Richard Dawkins once wrote a letter to his ten-year old daughter, explaining the difference between belief based on evidence versus authority. This letter addresses the appropriateness of extrapolating from evidence in making solid scientific conclusions. The title of this article from a book of Dawkins' essays entitled "A Devil's Chaplin," is "Good and Bad Reasons for Believing." And I do believe that any reasonable ten year old who keeps an open mind can see the difference. After all, we do informal science all day every day. The problem for some of us is when we start discussing the undeniable reality of humans as animals, thus highlighting our kinship with "lower" animals and suggesting that our creation was natural (and is ongoing). Understanding this basic point made by Dawkins doesn't require great intelligence. It requires intellectual courage. It requires that one quits screwing around with the burden of proof when testing propositions.

Continue ReadingBelief based on evidence vs. authority, and the appropriateness of extrapolation

Down with music! Understanding scientific “attacks” on religion.

Many of us who have advocated scientific examination of religions have experienced forceful push-back by those who are religious.   We scientific types don't always understand that reaction; our attitude is often "We study everything.  That's what we do.  It's better to know than not to know."  Folks who are religious…

Continue ReadingDown with music! Understanding scientific “attacks” on religion.