[This is a continuing series beginning with #1 and #2].

Long Pole – PFZ

There is yet a third vaccine coming on the market, let’s call it PFZ. It uses technology similar to MDN, injecting messengerRNA into the body, with instructions for building a part of the COVID19 virus necessary for the virus to function, but which by itself is not dangerous. The supply chain will be similar to MDN’s, with a major difference. PFZ must use a subset of cold chain logistics called super-cold chain, among other things. PFZ must be stored at -70C, or -94 Fahrenheit. This is close to the coldest surface temperature ever recorded on earth, -89.2 Celsius (-128.6 Fahrenheit), in Antarctica in 1983.

Manufacturing PFZ is done in a super-cold environment. The amount of energy needed to cool an entire manufacturing plant to -70 Celsius is significant, and the equipment isn’t easily maintained by a shade-tree mechanic. A lot of automation will be required, because humans don’t do well at those temperatures. Putting humans in heated suits runs the danger of heating the entire plant. Automated machinery will load vaccines into vials and vials into cold-storage sealed boxes. If dry ice is used, there are often two or three layers of boxes surrounding the 200 or 1,000 vials.

The packages are transported via truck or train to an airport/seaport for forwarding. Here is where the functions of manufacturing, distribution and retail probably deserve some information. Manufacturing produces products in quantity. It rarely sells single products to individual consumers, because it isn’t equipped to do so. It has no displays, no cash registers, no way to keep retail customers out of manufacturing areas once allowed inside the facility, it has no large call center to take orders, it cannot process credit card purchases – all of those are handled by retail organizations, which do them well. Manufacturers who sell directly to the public usually find that they’re competing with their own best customers, distributors.

The purpose of distribution is to deliver and buffer manufactured goods to retailers. Manufacturers produce in quantity, and distributors break down the quantity into bite-size chunks, store it, and send it to retailers when they need it. A retailer, such as a pharmacy or doctor’s office, has no use for a box of 1,000 vials of a vaccine, or 5,000 doses, because the retailer cannot serve that many customers for an injection in one day, especially of a vaccine that can’t be warmed, cooled, warmed. They rely on distributors to handle storage, breakdown and delivery.

With PFZ, retailers need to order exactly the number of doses needed for one day, and keep the boxed vials in refrigerated storage fortified by dry ice. Super-cold storage is expensive and rare. It is found in large hospitals for use with some laboratory specimens and some pathologists’ testing; it is also found in limited quantity in research institutions. Huge distributors, pharmacy chains and hospital groups are building new super-cold storage capability and have been for months.

I don’t pretend to know how the problem of sparsely-populated rural areas will be covered. The problem is called “The Traveling Salesman” by mathematicians and is different in every case. This has addressed PFZ in the First World, where a lot of cracks can be papered over with money and reallocation of resources. Cracks in Second- and Third-World countries are broader, deeper and more difficult to resolve. With enormous resolve and herculean effort, India can meet much of its need for MDN; it lacks the super-cold storage needed for PFZ.