I was discussing a social issue with a neighbor more than 10 years ago. I said something like “that really bothers me” or “I really care about that.” He stopped me and said something like this:
“If you really cared about it, you would be doing something about it.”
That stopped me in my tracks because the only thing I was doing was ranting. I think of this often when I hear the choruses of virtue signalers. They are almost everywhere. For instance, among those who Identify as Democrats, I constantly hear that the environment “is the most important issue” and that “it is an emergency situation” and that “no other issue comes close in importance.”
This is what I hear, constantly, from Democrats whose life style is indistinguishable from the life style of the average Republican. They drive similar gas-guzzling vehicles. They go on gas-guzzling vacations. They live in fuel guzzling houses. They live far from their places of work. They don’t car pool or (in my city) use mass transit or bike to work. They revel in getting take-out food and coffee sold by businesses that use single-use paper, plastic and foam wrappings. I’m still doing my research, but I found one 2013 study that concluded that Democrats generate only 5% less fossil fuel than Republicans per capita. They claim that this is an emergency situation but they don’t act like it is an emergency situation. If you asked the average Democrat to turn their thermostat down 5 degrees in the winter and put on a sweater, they will look at you like you are insane.
Apparently, that gives them the right to claim that they “care” and that Republicans don’t “care” about the environment.
The environment is merely one example of many. We are surrounded by virtue-signaling virtuosos of both political parties. But at least they all “care.”
I must agree. It isn’t so much the hypocrisy of Democrats, it is the betrayal. I’ve never been a Republican, and don’t see a reason for the Republican Party to exist. I became a liberal Democrat in 1960, inspired by JFK. I left the party and became a liberal independent in 2009. inspired by Nancy Pelosi. I suggested that her hearings into the misdeeds of the Bush Administration be held in zip code 01970.
I should periodically make it clear that I have never considered myself as belonging to either political party. I vote issue by issue. I criticize politicians issue by issue. Many people are afraid to take the leap into political independence, but it is liberating and exhilarating once you take the plunge.