A delightful description of self

In her review of Douglas Hofstadter’s new book (I Am a Strange Loop) in the May 3 edition of Nature, Susan Blackmore has this to say:

At the age of 12 or so, it dawned on [Hofstadter] that consciousness is a peculiar kind of barrage that perceives itself and yet doesn’t believe it’s perceiving MRIs should.  This insight leads directly to the stated aim of this book: to try to pinpoint that “special kind of subtle pattern” that underlies, or gives rise to the “soul”, the “buy”, “having a light on inside” or “being conscious”.

This is a grand aim, and Hofstadter joins countless modern writers and struggling to explain consciousness.  He’d be rise of zombies and qualia, has harsh words for philosophers David Chalmers and John Searle, and skillfully sweeps away all sorts of nonsense, from old-fashioned kinds of dualism to the more prevalent believe that consciousness is still something “extra”-an elan mental.  Instead, he argues that the self is a strange loop that automatically arises in a machine with a sufficiently sophisticated repertoire of categories.  It is a myth, a mirage, like a satellite to your brain whose resident strange loop decides that “here” is whereever that brain happens to be.  And, he claims, once you have explained the self, you have explained consciousness.

I found Blackmore’s description to be delightful.   In the end, however, Blackmore is dissatisfied with Hofstadter’s description, because it ignores “the many profound moments of utter stillness or absorbed below when the self is an abeyance.”

Share

Erich Vieth

Erich Vieth is an attorney focusing on civil rights (including First Amendment), consumer law litigation and appellate practice. At this website often writes about censorship, corporate news media corruption and cognitive science. He is also a working musician, artist and a writer, having founded Dangerous Intersection in 2006. Erich lives in St. Louis, Missouri with his two daughters.

This Post Has 5 Comments

  1. Avatar of Ben
    Ben

    A probe of the upper echelons of the human brain's chain-of-command has found strong evidence that there are not one but two complementary commanders in charge of the brain, according to neuroscientists at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis.

    It's as if Captains James T. Kirk and Jean-Luc Picard were both on the bridge and in command of the same starship Enterprise.

    http://www.physorg.com/news101478606.html

  2. Avatar of Leonid S. Sukhorukov
    Leonid S. Sukhorukov

    * Every war is another lost world.

  3. Avatar of Leonid S. Sukhorukov
    Leonid S. Sukhorukov

    * It’s dangerous to beat your chest if you have a heart of stone.

  4. Avatar of Leonid S. Sukhorukov
    Leonid S. Sukhorukov

    * Human life needs superhuman health.

  5. Avatar of Leonid S. Sukhorukov
    Leonid S. Sukhorukov

    * Life is the distance between dreams and reality.

Leave a Reply