Birther movement regarding Jesus

April 21, 2014 | By | 2 Replies More

This Tumblr website has launched a Birther movement regarding Jesus. It’s actually a challenge to present proof for an historical Jesus.

Please provide ONE single person, along with their authentic writing, that can prove the simple living-human, historical existence of the claimed, christian New Testament jesus the christ of Nazareth, that meets both (A & B) of our 2 simple requirements listed below:

A.) A contemporary 1st century person that lived between the years of 1-36 CE, who was a first-hand eye-witness, who actually saw, met, spoke to, and knew jesus personally.

B.) Provide this person’s original and authentic: secular, non-christian, non-religious, unbiased, non-bible, non-gospel, and non-scripture writing, that is directly about jesus (with references/citations to prove that this person actually wrote the work in question), officially dated by science, between the years of 1-53 CE. Additional religious or christian writings that can’t be used: papyri, uncials, minuscules, lectionaries, didache, apocrypha, gnostic, catechism, and pseudepigrapha.

In case some folks are tempted to reach for some of the classic “proofs,” the site offers this scorecard:

Jesus Chart


The site also offers links to many other sites that challenge the existence (not merely the divinity) of Jesus, including:

Bible Scholar: Robert M Price – Extrabiblical evidence for Jesus ► 8:44

Debunking the Fraudulent christian Apologist List of Extra-biblical but non-contemporary, claimed “sources” used as jesus “evidence.” (Jewish, “Pagan,” Non-christian, “Secular”)

The jesus Birther Movement (jBM) Research Database Directory

Research Articles, Evidence and Videos that Prove a Historical jesus, NEVER Existed

66 Famous Historians and Writers From The 1st and 2nd Century, Who Never Mentioned Fictional jesus – The Screaming Silence of Real History



Tags: , ,

Category: History, Religion

About the Author ()

Erich Vieth is an attorney focusing on consumer law litigation and appellate practice. He is also a working musician and a writer, having founded Dangerous Intersection in 2006. Erich lives in the Shaw Neighborhood of St. Louis, Missouri, where he lives half-time with his two extraordinary daughters.

Comments (2)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Just watched RT’s Abby Martin interview with Reza Aslan where he differentiates between the heavily mythologized Christ and the real life preacher, Jesus of Nazareth who in his opinion (and mine) actually existed. Once you see these as two different entities, it seems somewhat more likely than not that a real person inspired all that mythologizing. But until I invent that time machine, we’ll probably never know for sure.

    Also, it’s great poetic justice for actual Obama birthers to get wind of this movement, though the irony may be lost on them.

    • Erich Vieth says:

      Michael: I’ve read Bart Ehrman’s staunch defense of the idea that there was a person named Jesus (the name of the book is “Did Jesus Exist?”). Same thing as you suggested: Totally different thing to say A) someone named Jesus existed, versus B) he was the heavily mythologized Christ.

      Then again, I’m tantalized by the total absence of Jesus of Nazareth in the epistles, the only Christian writings for 40 years after the alleged death of the alleged Jesus. Earl Dougherty has written extensively on this. So has Robert Price.

      Too bad there isn’t a time machine. I could just take a photo of brown skinned Jesus, and a lot of so-called Christians would be SOOO disappointed. Sorry, but Jesus was not white skinned with blue eyes.

Leave a Reply