Treat all those who cheat the public like crooked locksmiths

| December 28, 2011 | 3 Replies

Here is an MSNBC feature on locksmiths who cheat people who call them in emergencies when they are locked out of their homes.  This news piece follows a tried and true formula for creating a good memorable story: It vividly exposes an unscrupulous practice, and then turns the camera on the perpetrators as they try to slink away.  To tell the complete story, the producers included the fact that there are honest people in the trade (in this case, honest locksmiths); locksmiths can make a living while giving people a fair shake.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Why, then, don’t networks treat all of those who lie, cheat and steal with comparable scrutiny? What I have in mind are Wall Street Banks, telecoms, fossil fuel industries, healthcare insurers, the defense industries and other powerful entities who have purchased Congress and then made certain that industry reform is impossible. These industries have driven out competition and/or figured out how to freely feed out of the public trough. They’ve been gouging consumers, directly and indirectly, in ways that make the crooked fees charged by locksmiths look like chump change. Consider this recent article by Matt Taibbi, illustrating how big banks are cheating taxpayers.

Consider also how Barack Obama’s promise of an expanded industry of energy conservation and sustainable energy production would be a centerpiece of his Administration.  Though he has done some good things, has also opened up large tracts of Western lands to coal mining and providing much more funding to nuclear and fossil fuel than to green alternatives.  This is one of many of Obama’s broken promises– somehow, indefinite warmongering against undefined enemies is somehow much more important that having a sustainable economy back home. And even after “health care reform,” people who had health insurance are struggling mightily to pay uncovered medical bills, many of them tipping over into bankruptcy. Payday lenders run rampant across the country.   A few months ago,  telecoms almost succeeded in destroying what is left of net neutrality.

These sorts of thing don’t just happen; powerful people are consciously making these terrible decisions, and they (including most of our politicians) are motivated by money, not public service.

I fear that one of the main reasons we are cleaning up these industries is that too many Americans are math challenged — they suffer from innumeracy. And most Americans would flunk a basic test on American civics and history.   Foxes run rampant in the American hen house.  One would need to spend some serious time thinking about the effects of lack of competition in order to appreciate how much the public is being fleeced, but Americans are highly distracted with TV and other forms of entertainment.   Another hurdle is that big media is owned by big companies and serves big industries by selling them commercials. Thus, we don’t see constant aggressive journalism illustrating how the public is being ripped off by many (by no means all) big businesses.

Don’t expect the journalism to get better, especially for the reasons outlined by John Nichols of Free Press. Expect things to get worse, in light of the fact that this week the  FCC proposed a new set of rules that would unleash a wave of media consolidation across the country. If the agency’s proposal sounds familiar, that’s because it’s nearly identical to rules the FCC proposed during the Bush administration.  This proposal is especially scandalous for the reasons stated here.

An additional hurdle to getting these stories out is to make them simple and memorable stories, but this is quite a challenge. These industries have successfully complexified themselves–it now takes “experts” (including teams of lawyers) to understand how these industries function. Ordinary people don’t have much of a chance of even articulating how and why they are getting ripped off, much less understanding what can be done to fix the problems.   Complexity is not an accident–it is a tactic.   Consolidating the mass media isn’t simply happening–it is a tactic of big business to maintain control, as are recent attempts to give private businesses the power to shut down internet domains without a court order.

There is no incentive for the mass media to excoriate those behind any of these proposals.   There is little to no incentive for big media to descend on those behind these movements as though they were crooked locksmiths.   If only.

Share

Category: American Culture, Corporatocracy, Corruption, Journalism, Media, Orwellian

About the Author ()

Erich Vieth is an attorney focusing on consumer law litigation and appellate practice. He is also a working musician and a writer, having founded Dangerous Intersection in 2006. Erich and his wife, Anne Jay, live in the Shaw Neighborhood of St. Louis, Missouri, where they are raising their two extraordinary daughters.

Comments (3)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. They should be behind the bars not charging us 685.00 for a simple lockout. I am a licensed locksmith in Nashville TN and we are having the same problem over here, The bad thing is Companies like a yellow pages don’t even ask them to provide a valid licensed number in order to put their ad on yellow pages book and their online directory .

    It is getting worse and we all have to do something about it, I can not believe it how the fat boy destroyed that simple kwickset doorknob.
    Shame on Him.

  2. Niklaus Pfirsig says:

    ABC Lock Key Inc:
    I decided long ago that local businesses with a history are the best. Service pro, (formally Donelson conditioning) has been my goto guys for heating and air, Johnsons Hardware for hard to find hardware needs, and so forth. Your company, is one of a half dozen or so Nashville locksmiths that have been around for a while. To me a local business with staying power indicates they must be doing something right.

    Over the years, I’ve seen expose’ paces covering mechanics to lawn services to daycare centers that follow the formula of the locksmith piece. They tend to slant the story a little to make the problem look worse, but they at least show one or two honest service people.

    I think Erich is ragging on how little attention the mainstream media pays to corporate businesses involved in fraudulent practices that are equally bad if not worse. Think of how Bill Heard (the auto dealership chain) avoided media scrutiny for years while ripping off its customers.

  3. These people destroy the reputation of any person involved in locksmith jobs. In New York I hear at least once a month about people who have been cheated by “locksmith”. Too bad.

Leave a Reply


Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.