That disconnect between Catholics and their Church

December 7, 2008 | By | 2 Replies More

At Daylight Atheism, Ebonmuse discusses the disconnect between the Catholic Church and lay Catholics:

To judge by some recent news articles, the Catholic church, which at least used to stand for good education, has become infected with the same anti-intellectual disease that pervades so many sects of evangelical Protestantism.

What are the problems with the Catholic Church?  It’s the same problems with fundamentalist sects:

…young Catholics feel increasingly disconnected from a church that continues to bash gays, exclude women from the priesthood, and preach against contraception. As society becomes increasingly liberal and tolerant, the Catholic church continues to cling obstinately to its irrational rules, and is accordingly being left in the dust.

This post by Ebonmuse reminded me of the many well-educated and thoughtful Catholics I know.  Many of them are good friends.   I often wonder how they can stand it when they discuss how the Church that has been their Church for their entire lives increasingly turns to the fringe right.  I wonder how many Catholics are having fantasies (or plans) to break away and start fresh . . .

Truly, how is it that in a world rife with massive moral challenges, the Church maintains such a constant focus on abortion, gays and birth control?  I know that the congregations have much more than that on their minds, but there does seem to be such a disconnect between the congregation and the highest level of the clergy.

Feel free to join the conversation over at Daylight Atheism.


Tags: , ,

Category: Good and Evil, Religion

About the Author ()

Erich Vieth is an attorney focusing on consumer law litigation and appellate practice. He is also a working musician and a writer, having founded Dangerous Intersection in 2006. Erich lives in the Shaw Neighborhood of St. Louis, Missouri, where he lives half-time with his two extraordinary daughters.

Comments (2)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Erich writes:—"Truly, how is it that in a world rife with massive moral challenges, the Church maintains such a constant focus on abortion, gays and birth control?"

    By making the assumption that as we conduct ourselves in private, over personal issues, so we would conduct ourselves in public, over community issues. The flaw is in tagging these behaviors as those pivot points around which personal morality manifests or fails.

  2. Tim Hogan says:

    Naw, youse guys has it all wrong! What the Church says isn’t what you peg as being what the Church says, it’s your listening for what you already say is so. Certainly, there are reactionaries or “Neocons” in the Church. I have even written about such.

    But, recently, the National Conference of Catholic Bishops (NCCB) re-affirmed its prior well reasoned guide for the formation of Catholic conscience in the political sphere and specifically called out the neocons as imprudently focusing on only parts of Catholic teachings on faith and morals saying the equivalent of “it’s Catholic doctrine and we aren’t going to change it just because you’d like it to change.”

Leave a Reply