Recounting the dead in Iraq
Many of us remember a scientific paper released back in October 2006. It claimed that more than a half-million Iraqi people had died as a result of the US invasion. The paper, published in Lancet, has been attacked ferociously by the Bush administration.
The March 1, 2007 issue of Nature (only available to subscribers online) describes the methodology of that study, which was conducted by authors based at Johns Hopkins University and Al Mustansiriya University in Baghdad. The data was gathered through interviews conducted by two teams of four members each. Nature asked one of the Iraqi researchers involved in the data collection some follow-up questions regarding the methodology. He “asked not to be named because he fears that press attention could make him the target of attacks.”
The raw data gathered by the study is now being released to both critics and supporters of the results of the study. This analysis might enable researchers to determine whether the Iraqi interviewers exaggerated the results for political reasons. “That could show up and unusual patterns within the data.”
Here is the intriguing final paragraph of the Nature article:
[S]upporters say that criticisms should not detract from the fact that the Iraqi team managed to produce a survey under extremely difficult circumstances. Security threats forced the team to change travel plans and at one point to consider canceling the survey altogether. Since its completion, one interviewer has been killed and another has left Baghdad, although it is not known whether either case is linked to their involvement in the survey. Either way, the continuing violence in the country is enough for the remaining interviewers to say that they are not willing to repeat the exercise.
- The price of Iraqi “freedom” is much higher than advertised. The U.S. suppresses stats on dead Iraqis and maimed Americans
- The killing fields of Iraq
- Why did only a few of us oppose the Iraq invasion?
- How many lies did the Bush Administration tell in the 2 years prior to the Iraq invasion?
- Gov. Richardson: remove all U.S. troops from Iraq “as soon as possible.”
